Tampilkan postingan dengan label Tony Budidjaja. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label Tony Budidjaja. Tampilkan semua postingan

Kamis, 13 Maret 2014

(Don’t) Kill foreign lawyers

(Don’t) Kill foreign lawyers

Tony Budidjaja  ;   Principal of Budidjaja & Associates,
Chairman of the Indonesian Christian Legal Society (ICLS).
JAKARTA POST,  12 Maret 2014
                                                                                                                       
                                                                                         
                                                                                                             
It is hard to believe that to this day no clear rules have been put in place with regards to the practice of foreign lawyers in Indonesia. The country certainly lags far behind neighboring countries such as Singapore when it comes to the issue.

The only piece of legislation in Indonesia that deals with foreign law practice is Article 23 of the 2003 Law on advocates. Paragraph (1) of this article stipulates that foreign lawyers are not allowed to appear in court under any circumstances or open their own offices (including representative offices) in Indonesia.

The only exception to this rule is provided in Paragraph (2), which says that a foreign lawyer can work in Indonesia only if he/she is employed by an Indonesian law firm as a staff member or advisor on foreign law, and his/her employment requires prior approval from Indonesia’s Law and Human Rights Ministry following a recommendation from the Advocates Organization. Furthermore, during their employment in Indonesia, based on Article 23 (3), the foreign lawyer must provide free legal services in the form of legal education and research.

Realizing that the wording of the aforementioned provisions is so basic, Article 23 (4) of the Advocates Law requires the Law ministry to issue an implementing regulation to detail the procedure for employing foreign lawyers and mechanism to provide mandatory free legal services. On Dec. 17, 2004 the ministry issued a decree concerning the issue, but unfortunately, some of the provisions in the decree are not sufficiently clear.

Although the Advocates Law restricts foreign lawyers from establishing offices in Indonesia, some law firms have found a loophole by incorporating their firms with business consulting companies and openly offer services to businesses in Indonesia. Besides, many international law firms are affiliated with Indonesian firms to enable them to do business here.

In the past few years, such arrangements have increased. They seem to have ignored the policy that restricts foreign lawyers from engaging in legal services in Indonesia.

A number of overseas law firms have deliberately employed Indonesians as a means to tap into the market. They must be aware that under the Advocates Law, unless a person has been admitted to the Indonesian Advocates Organization, it will be illegal for him/her to practice law in Indonesia.

Many foreign lawyers simply provide services to their Indonesian clients, when needed. They work by flying into Indonesia to cater to the needs of their client. They must be reminded that business visas may not be sufficient to continuously fly-in and fly-out of Indonesia for the purpose of practicing law in Indonesia.

The massive influx of foreign lawyers and the growing influence of foreign lawyers in the Indonesia’s legal services market have raised concerns among Indonesian lawyers. Therefore, it is no surprise that when interviewed by The Financial Times recently, Otto Hasibuan (Chairman of PERADI — one of the largest advocates associations in Indonesia) said: “If we want to protect our lawyers, we must not allow foreign lawyers to practice here.”

After remaining silent since on the issue since its inception in 2005, PERADI recently made an unusual policy by requiring foreign lawyers who want to work or continue to work in Indonesia to take a legal course and an exam on the Code of Ethics of Indonesian Advocates. Simultaneously, PERADI has warned that failure to comply with these requirements can lead to difficulties for foreign lawyer applying for a work permit in Indonesia to obtain a PERADI recommendation.

This policy clearly suggests that PERADI has taken a firm stance toward foreign lawyers. This cannot be perceived as a move to pave the way for the foreign lawyers to practice Indonesian law, which may have been misunderstood by some. The present Advocates Act only allows Indonesian citizens to practice Indonesian law.

The dubious and uncontrolled practice of foreign lawyers, combined with the absence of a good regulatory system, will potentially trigger chaos in the legal services sector. To facilitate fair play in the legal services market, the dos and don’ts relating to the practice of foreign lawyers in the country is urgently needed. The lack of regulation on foreign lawyers will discourage qualified foreign lawyers with genuine commitments to help develop Indonesia’s legal profession and the Indonesian economy from entering the country.

As Indonesia has been required to gradually eliminate the barriers of entry for foreign lawyers, the Law ministry decree should be amended pending the enactment of the new Advocates Act. Appropriate provisions on the qualifications of foreign lawyers permitted to practice in Indonesia should be in place. For example, a requirement should state that in order for foreign lawyers to practice in Indonesia, they must meet specific standards related to experience, expertise as well as commitment in developing Indonesia’s legal professionals. If legal matters related to Indonesian law are to be handled exclusively by Indonesian lawyers, then it will be necessary to include a provision that restricts law firms that have entered into formal associations with foreign firms to provide any advice based on Indonesian law.

It would also be necessary to create a competent and sustainable body to oversee the activities of the foreign lawyers and to set up an effective system to monitor the implementation of the transfer of knowledge and skills by the foreign lawyers for the betterment of Indonesian legal professionals and for civil society in general.

On a parallel front, initiating reforms in the legal education and training sector is necessary to ensure availability of a superior talent pool in the legal sector. In addition to level legal courses, today’s lawyers  need to learn about the role of information technology in delivering legal services and acquire relevant soft skills in order to stay sustainable in the Indonesian legal industry. ●

Kamis, 11 April 2013

The future of Indonesia’s legal profession : A lawyer perspective


The future of Indonesia’s legal profession :
A lawyer perspective
Tony Budidjaja  ;  An Executive Committee Member of Law Association for Asia and the Pacific (LAWASIA)
JAKARTA POST, 11 April 2013

  
Being one of the largest emerging and developing markets in Asia, Indonesia is indeed a key influence in the Asian economy.

As an Indonesian lawyer, I feel proud but at the same time worried about how Indonesia will evolve.

Indonesia’s legal system and infrastructure are outdated and may be ill-suited to keep up with the growth of its economy. While it is believed that Indonesia is becoming one of Asia’s most powerful economies, the country’s legal industry however, is not as powerful as some people may think. At the present moment Indonesia has many challenges to overcome to become an Asian legal superpower.

Indonesia’s biggest challenge is its obsolete and complicated legal system as well as weak legal infrastructure. Since independence in 1945, there has been a general trend toward replacing outdated Dutch laws with those enacted by the legislative body.

Yet, many Dutch laws remain in place. As a matter of fact, most court actions taken in Indonesia are still initiated by reference to a provision in the Civil Code, which is a replica of the 1838 Dutch Civil Code.

In addition to the civil law system, other legal systems, such as customary law and Islamic law, are still applied across Indonesia in a non-western context, and they serve as an influential force in various aspects such as family and inheritance. Besides, Indonesia has been enacting many statute laws that are heavily influenced by the common law.

Despite Indonesia’s huge gross domestic product (GDP) and economic growth of around 6 percent per year in the past few years, in my view, Indonesia should still be regarded as a “third world” country in terms of the development of its legal profession, its legal educational and professional training system, as well as its judicial performance.

Generally, the legal profession in Indonesia remains underdeveloped. The number of lawyers in Indonesia, a country with a population of more than 240 million, is very low.
The members of the Indonesian Advocates Association (PERADI) throughout Indonesia are “only” about 22,000. In Indonesia one lawyer serves about 11,000 people, while in the US the ratio of lawyers to the population stands at one lawyer for 265 Americans.

Pursuant to the Indonesian Advocates Law, these two roles are fused under one title: “advocate”. Therefore, from the perspective of the Advocates Law, when someone has attained the status of an advocate, he or she is deemed competent to perform in both representing clients in the court proceedings and giving specialist legal advice to clients on various matters affecting their legal rights, including transactional work.

While specialization is becoming more and more important to the workings of the lawyers, it seems that many Indonesian lawyers are still attempting to be generalists.

Most Indonesian law firms are family owned and, thus, fall behind in terms of the management and professional approach compared to modern law firms in developed countries.

Nonetheless, generally speaking Indonesian lawyers have a comparative strength. Foreign lawyers are not usually able to prevail over their domestic counterparts’ work endurance, creativity and interpersonal relationships. Indonesian lawyers generally have the power to withstand all work related stress, be it physical, emotional or mental. They usually find it very easy to adapt to any changes.

While Indonesia has many talented individuals who could be developed to compete with foreign lawyers, there are too many out-of-date and unnecessary restrictions that Indonesian lawyers are subjected to, which restrict their ability to compete with foreign lawyers. For instance, Indonesian lawyers are discouraged from entering into a multi interdisciplinary partnership or having an outside investor.

Furthermore, Indonesian lawyers are precluded from advertising and marketing their services.

In Indonesia, only lawyers may have an ownership interest in a law firm and a legal service provider cannot be incorporated as a company. Only a “natural person” or “civil partnership” can provide legal services.

On the other hand, in some countries (like Australia and Hong Kong) law firms are permitted to raise capital through initial public offerings on the stock market, like most corporations.

That’s why allowing the entry of foreign lawyers into Indonesia without first putting native lawyers on an equal footing would be considered unjust and put them at a competitive disadvantage.

While the country’s law schools have prepared young generations to become future lawyers, many are unprepared to practice as an advocate due to lack of practical training.

Furthermore, the process to become an advocate in Indonesia is arduous. For instance, the Advocates Law does not allow them to start their professional legal practice until they have reached 25 years old and been granted an advocate certificate, which quite often takes months.

As lawyers have the power to influence the country’s economic growth, Indonesian legal professional training system needs improvement to ensure that Indonesian lawyers have the strength of character and competency to meet both increased expectations and complexity of modern legal work. It is better to allow young lawyers to practice as early as possible.

Last but not least, the Indonesian court system does not provide effective and efficient recourses to resolve commercial disputes. The Civil Procedure Law needs updating as it was not designed to adequately address commercial or international disputes.

The national court system is understandably regarded with trepidation by foreign investors. Their most frequent complaints are that judges are generally unfamiliar with sophisticated commercial transactions; and that some judges are susceptible to bribery, political influence and the pressure of public opinion.

As these factors are undoubtedly issues, the quality of the judiciary must be improved through skill development and intellectual capacity building.

The best way for us to deal with the challenges is to recognize our limitations as well as our potential and stop blaming external circumstances. Through legal reform efforts, Indonesia will be able to lead future development in Asia. ●